Florida's attorney general targets a Bradenton private school over expulsions and tuition. The school says he has the facts wrong.
James Uthmeier says Saint Stephen's Episcopal School may have broken Florida's consumer protection law after families objected to classroom materials. The school says the families were separated for conduct, not complaints, and has until Nov. 30 to respond.
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier is using the state’s consumer protection law to press a private school, a move that could matter to every private school that publishes a handbook or signs enrollment contracts with families.
What the attorney general says
In a letter last week to Saint Stephen’s Episcopal School in Bradenton, Uthmeier accused the school of expelling the children of parents who complained about middle school classroom materials they considered sexually explicit, then keeping the families’ full-year tuition, the Sarasota Herald-Tribune reported. His office says the school may have violated the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act by misrepresenting what families were paying for, according to ABC7 WWSB.
His office has demanded that the school preserve all related records, stop trying to collect tuition from the affected families, stop withholding their children’s transcripts and make the families whole. The school was given until Nov. 30 to respond.
At a Tampa news conference on Nov. 16, Uthmeier said his office was not yet calling the matter an investigation, according to FOX 13 Tampa Bay. He argued that a school that markets itself as protecting children from mature content has to “live up to that marketing,” and that private schools are “not completely immune” from government oversight. At least two families appear to be involved, FOX 13 reported. Neither the families nor the students have been publicly identified, and Education Press is not identifying them.
According to the attorney general’s letter, as reported by the Herald-Tribune, the school’s enrollment contract makes parents liable for the full year’s tuition and fees, or any unpaid balance, if a student withdraws voluntarily or involuntarily.
What the school says
Head of School Peter Kraft disputed key parts of the attorney general’s account in an email to parents and staff, WUSF reported. Kraft wrote that the students “were not expelled” and that their families were separated from the school because of “repeated and serious violations” of its Civility Clause. He said the decision followed several incidents that went beyond the parents’ concerns about middle school reading, and that the literature in question contains no sexually explicit material.
Kraft also said the tuition claims are false, writing that the families’ monthly payments stopped after their separation date and any credits were refunded. The school has said it will cooperate fully with the attorney general’s office and is confident it acted ethically and within Florida law.
Why it matters for private schools
This case tests whether promises in handbooks, marketing and enrollment contracts can be enforced as consumer protection matters when a dispute with families turns into a separation and a tuition fight.
For school leaders, the practical takeaways are plain. Make sure what a handbook says about curriculum matches what is taught. Make sure conduct policies such as civility clauses spell out the process before a family is asked to leave. And review how tuition, refunds and records are handled when an enrollment ends midyear, since withholding transcripts over a balance is one of the issues the attorney general raised.
Education Press will follow up after the Nov. 30 response deadline.
How this story was made: This article was drafted with the help of AI tools using the public sources listed above, then reviewed, fact-checked, and approved by a human editor. Read our AI Use Policy.
See something wrong? Request a correction. Have a story from your school? Submit it here.