Independent education news from every corner of the country
by School Success
Your place for education news
News · National · Policy

Education Department opens privacy investigations into 5 districts over 'gender support plans'

The department's Student Privacy Policy Office says it will check whether districts in Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Colorado, Illinois and Minnesota broke federal parental-rights laws. Eau Claire says it has not heard from the department directly, and Colonial says it just received notice.

By Education Press Staff3 min readAI-assisted, editor reviewed

The U.S. Department of Education said Wednesday it has opened investigations into five school districts over forms and policies that it says can keep parents from learning about a child’s gender identity at school.

The cases are being handled by the department’s Student Privacy Policy Office, not its Office for Civil Rights. That matters for every school leader, because the office is relying on two student privacy laws that apply to nearly every district and many other schools that take federal money.

Which districts

According to the department’s announcement, the districts are:

  • Colonial School District in Pennsylvania
  • Eau Claire Area School District in Wisconsin
  • Thompson School District in Colorado
  • Community Unit School District 300 in Illinois
  • St. Paul Public Schools in Minnesota

The department points to “Gender Support Plans” or similar forms that, it says, ask students about preferred names and pronouns, support at school, and whether parents know. It also says several districts keep these plans in separate filing systems, and some policies let staff use a student’s legal name and sex when talking with parents while using a different name at school.

The two laws in play

The department says it will decide whether the districts violated:

  • The Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment (PPRA), which requires notice and written parental consent before schools survey or evaluate students on certain sensitive topics, such as sex behaviors and attitudes or mental and psychological problems.
  • The Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA), which gives parents the right to see their child’s education records and ask for corrections.

The department argues that treating these plans as “temporary records,” storing them separately, or withholding them from parents infringes on FERPA rights. It said violations can lead to enforcement and possible loss of federal funding. It also pointed to guidance letters the office issued in March 2025 and August 2026, and to Oct. 5, 2026 letters the department and the Justice Department sent to every state attorney general about mental health screenings in schools.

“The law is clear: schools do not decide what information is shared with parents, the law does,” Frank Miller, director of the Student Privacy Policy Office, said in the release.

What the districts say

The Eau Claire Area School District told WEAU it learned of the investigation through local media and had not received any direct communication from the department. The district said it takes its legal obligations seriously and will respond once the department contacts it.

A Colonial School District spokesperson told The Philadelphia Inquirer the district had just received notice and does not comment on legal matters. The spokesperson said the policy has been in place since 2019. The Inquirer also noted that advocates for transgender students say no law requires schools to tell parents when a student identifies as transgender to a staff member.

We did not find public responses from the other three districts as of Thursday morning.

Why it matters

These are investigations, not findings. But the approach is new. By framing the issue as a records and consent question, the department is signaling that it sees separate files and student surveys as privacy problems that any district could face.

For school leaders, it is a good moment to review:

  • Where student support plans and counseling notes are stored, and whether they count as education records parents can request.
  • Whether any student form asks about topics covered by PPRA, and whether parental consent is collected first.
  • How staff communicate names and pronouns with families.

For parents, FERPA already gives the right to request a child’s education records from any school that receives federal education funds.

Sources

How this story was made: This article was drafted with the help of AI tools using the public sources listed above, then reviewed, fact-checked, and approved by a human editor. Read our AI Use Policy.

See something wrong? Request a correction. Have a story from your school? Submit it here.