Independent education news from every corner of the country
by School Success
Your place for education news
News · National · Policy

IRS adds a second hearing day on its plan to tie private school tax exemptions to race-neutral scholarships and admissions

The proposed rule would end an old IRS allowance for private school programs that favor minority students. Speakers will be heard by phone Dec. 2 and 3, and schools would have to comply starting with tax years that begin after May 31, 2027.

By Education Press Staff3 min readAI-assisted, editor reviewed

So many people asked to testify on a proposed IRS rule about race and private school tax exemptions that the agency has added a second day to the public hearing. A notice in the Nov. 18 Federal Register says the telephone hearing will now run Wednesday, Dec. 2, and Thursday, Dec. 3, starting at 10 a.m. ET both days.

The rule has drawn far less attention than other federal school choice news this fall, but it reaches almost every private school, college and university that holds 501(c)(3) status. Here is what it would do and what school leaders should know.

What the rule would change

For decades, the IRS has said a private school cannot be tax-exempt if it discriminates by race. That position goes back to a 1971 federal court case and a 1971 revenue ruling, and the Supreme Court upheld it in the 1983 Bob Jones University case, according to the proposed rule published Sept. 4.

But a 1975 IRS guidance document, Revenue Procedure 75-50, carved out an exception. It said a school policy favoring racial minority groups in admissions, programs or financial aid would not count as discrimination if the goal was to support the school’s nondiscriminatory policy. It also said scholarships and loans favoring minority students would not hurt a school’s exempt status.

The proposed rule would write the nondiscrimination requirement into the tax regulations and delete those exceptions. Under the proposal, discrimination by race, color, or national or ethnic origin would bar tax exemption no matter the intent, including when a school describes it as remedial or diversity-related. It would cover admissions, scholarships, loans, athletics and other school-run programs.

Who it affects

Treasury and the IRS estimate the rule could affect about 18,000 tax-exempt private elementary, secondary and postsecondary schools and about 750,000 students who may qualify for scholarships based on race, ethnicity or national identity, according to the proposal. It could also affect donors who give to scholarship funds with race-based criteria.

The agencies say they expect colleges already changed admissions after the Supreme Court’s 2023 Students for Fair Admissions decision, so for them the main effect would be on scholarships and loans. They also say they do not have data on how many private K-12 schools currently consider race in admissions.

What it does not do

The proposal says private schools could still keep a religious mission and select students based on religious affiliation or membership. A religious admissions rule would not become racial discrimination simply because members of a faith community share ancestry, as long as the rule is based only on religion. Schools could also still work to reduce prejudice, as long as they do not use race-based policies to do it.

Timeline

The comment period and the deadline to ask to speak both closed Nov. 3. Only people who asked by then will testify, with 10 minutes each, according to the hearing notice. Anyone who wants to listen without speaking must email publichearings@irs.gov by Nov. 30 with “REG-119986-25” and “ATTEND Hearing Telephonically” in the subject line.

Treasury and the IRS say they expect to finalize the rule before May 31, 2027. It would apply to school tax years that begin after that date, which the agencies say gives schools time to revise admissions or scholarship policies.

What school leaders can do now

Private school heads and business officers may want to review admissions criteria, named scholarships and donor-restricted aid funds for any race, ethnicity or national origin requirement, and talk with tax counsel about how a final rule could apply to their fiscal year.

How this story was made: This article was drafted with the help of AI tools using the public sources listed above, then reviewed, fact-checked, and approved by a human editor. Read our AI Use Policy.

See something wrong? Request a correction. Have a story from your school? Submit it here.

National · Policy

Education Department opens privacy investigations into 5 districts over 'gender support plans'

The department's Student Privacy Policy Office says it will check whether districts in Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Colorado, Illinois and Minnesota broke federal parental-rights laws. Eau Claire says it has not heard from the department directly, and Colonial says it just received notice.