Education Department opens civil rights probes into teacher-recruitment programs for men and teachers of color
Federal investigators are looking at NYC Men Teach, Maryland and Minnesota teacher diversity grants and scholarships, and programs at 11 colleges. Here is what is under review and what it could mean for aspiring teachers.
Programs built to bring more men and more teachers of color into classrooms are now under federal civil rights investigation.
The U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights opened the investigations on Nov. 13 and announced them on Nov. 16, according to the department’s release. The office said it will decide whether the programs violate Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which bars discrimination based on race, color or national origin in federally funded programs, or Title IX, which bars sex discrimination.
K-12 Dive described the move as one of the first times the office has used civil rights law to challenge diversity efforts in teacher scholarships, recruitment and training.
What is under investigation
The department named four sets of programs:
- City University of New York: whether CUNY discriminates by race and sex through its NYC Men Teach program.
- University of Maryland School of Education: whether it discriminates by race through the Maryland Higher Education Commission’s Teacher Quality and Diversity Grant Program and the EdTerps CARES Network.
- Minnesota Department of Education: whether its Education Tuition Assistance Program, which gives scholarships and stipends to teacher candidates, discriminates by race.
- Minnesota Office of Higher Education: whether the Minnesota Aspiring Teachers of Color Scholarship Pilot Program and the Underrepresented Student Teacher Grant discriminate by race. The department said both tied eligibility to the applicant’s race.
The office also opened 11 more investigations into colleges over what it called race- or sex-exclusive scholarships and programs. The release lists the University of California, Berkeley; UCLA; Campbell University; Drake University; College of DuPage; Middle Tennessee State University; the University of Tennessee, Knoxville; the University of San Diego; Seattle University; Westfield State University; and a school listed as the “University of North Iowa.”
What the department and the states say
“Race, national origin, or sex should not decide who will shape America’s next generation,” Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights Kimberly Richey said in the release. She said agencies and colleges that use those factors to withhold opportunities from teacher candidates “violate federal law.”
A spokesperson for the Minnesota Office of Higher Education told WORLD that one of the flagged scholarships was discontinued last year and that the other grant was created by state lawmakers in 2021 and run according to state law. WORLD said CUNY, the University of Maryland and the Minnesota Department of Education had not responded to its requests for comment.
CUNY told K-12 Dive that its “programs are open to all students regardless of race, gender or national origin.”
Opening an investigation is not a finding of wrongdoing. The department has not said how long the reviews will take.
Why it matters for schools
Many districts lean on university and state “grow your own” pipelines to fill hard-to-staff jobs. Programs aimed at men and teachers of color are one of the tools some states and universities use to widen that pipeline.
If these investigations lead programs to change their eligibility rules, the money may not disappear. Some programs could open to all applicants or switch to criteria such as financial need, a commitment to teach in a high-need school or a shortage subject. Others could pause while the cases are open.
What aspiring teachers and school leaders can do
- If you have a scholarship or stipend from one of these programs, contact the program office and ask whether your award or next payment is affected. Nothing in the release says current awards are canceled.
- If you are applying, read the current eligibility rules closely. They may change mid-cycle.
- If your district partners with one of these programs, ask your university or state partner whether recruitment pipelines or placement agreements will change for next school year.
We will follow these cases as the department and the programs respond.
How this story was made: This article was drafted with the help of AI tools using the public sources listed above, then reviewed, fact-checked, and approved by a human editor. Read our AI Use Policy.
See something wrong? Request a correction. Have a story from your school? Submit it here.